【GRE里一道逻辑题,请赐教!Editorial:Criticsofnuclearpowercomplainabouttheallegedlyseriousharmthatmightresultfromcontinuedoperationofexistingnuclearpowerplants.Butsuchconcernsdonotjustifyclosingtheseplants;afterall】
GRE里一道逻辑题,请赐教!
Editorial:
Criticsofnuclearpowercomplainabouttheallegedlyseriousharmthatmightresultfromcontinuedoperationofexistingnuclearpowerplants.Butsuchconcernsdonotjustifyclosingtheseplants;afterall,theiroperationhascausednomoreharmthanthatcausedbypollutiongeneratedbycoal-andoil-burningpowerplants,themostimportantothersourcesofenergy.
Whichofthefollowingisanassumptiononwhichtheargumentdepends?
(A)Existingnuclearpowerplantsshouldbeclosedonlyifitcanbeconclusivelydemonstratedthattheircontinuedoperationislikelytocauseharmmoreseriousthantheharmtheiroperationhasalreadycaused.
(B)Closingexistingnuclearpowerplantswouldrequiregreatlyincreasedrelianceoncoal-andoil-burningpowerplants.
(C)Theharmthathasresultedfromoperationofexistingcoal-andoil-burningpowerplantshasbeensignificant.
(D)Theharmthatanuclearpowerplantislikelytocauseasitcontinuestooperatecanbereliablypredictedfromthepasthistoryofnuclearpowerplants.
(E)Theonlyharmthathasresultedfromoperationofexistingcoal-andoil-burningpowerplantshasresultedfromthepollutiongeneratedbytheseplants.
答案是D,我真心没明白...