【英语翻译SeeWoodard,991S.W.2dat796-查字典问答网

来自时彧的问题

　　【英语翻译SeeWoodard,991S.W.2dat796-97. We,therefore,reaffirmthegeneralruleappliedinWoodardthatcourts“shouldnotgrantmandamusrelieftothecomplainingpartyonarecusalmotionunder[Rule18a]becausethepartyhasanadeq】

　　英语翻译

　　SeeWoodard,991S.W.2dat796-97. We,therefore,reaffirmthegeneralruleappliedinWoodardthatcourts“shouldnotgrantmandamusrelieftothecomplainingpartyonarecusalmotionunder[Rule18a]becausethepartyhasanadequateremedyatlawbywayofanappealfromthefinaljudgment.” SeeMcClenan,661S.W.2dat111. Moreover,McClenan(whichwehaveoverruledonothergroundsearlierinthisopinion)demonstratesthatatrialjudge'sfailuretocomplywithRule18acanbeharmlesswheretherecorddemonstratesthatthetrialjudgewasnotbiased. SeeWoodard,991S.W.2dat797(trialjudgeallegedlyfailedtocomplywithRule18abynotreferringthedefendant'sfourthrecusalmotionforanotherjudgetodecide); McClenan,661S.W.2dat110-11(trialjudgeerredbyfailingtoreferdefendant'srecusalmotionforanotherjudgetodecide). Thoughbothofthesecasesinvolvedatrialjudge'sallegedfailuretocomplywithRule18a,neitheroftheminvolvedasituationwherethetrialjudge'sbiaswasestablishedasamatteroflaw. Decidingthatrespondent'sbiasintheDeLeoncasehasbeenestablishedasamatteroflawdistinguishesthiscasefromcasessuchasWoodardandMcClenan. 4

1回答

2020-10-30 04:17

我要回答

请先登录

裴晓芳

　　参见Woodard,991S.W.2dat796-97.我们因此再度确认Woodard案中所使用的一般规则为“不应[在规则第18条a款项下]就回避动议给予申诉方救济命令书,因为该方在法律上通过对最终判决的上诉有合适的救济渠道".参见McClenan,661S.W.2dat111.此外,McClenan案中（我们在早先的意见中基于其他理由驳回了判决）显示了审判法官未能遵守规则第18条a款是无害的,记录显示审判法官并无偏见.参见Woodard,991S.W.2dat797（审判法官据称由于未将被告的第四次回避动议提交给另一位法官决定,因而违反了规则第18条a款）,参见 McClenan,661S.W.2dat110-11（审判法官未能将被告的回避动议提交给另一位法官来决定是错误的）.通过上述两个涉及审判法官据称未能遵守规则18条a款的案例,它们都没有涉及一种情况,那就是审判法官的偏见被确立为一项法律问题.DeLeon

　　案中,决定被申请人的偏见被确立为一项法律问题,因而此案同其他案件如Woodard案和McClenan不同.

　　供参考,

2020-10-30 04:21:34

最新问答

推荐文章

猜你喜欢

附近的人在看

推荐阅读

拓展阅读